When I was a teenager, one of my aunts was asking me about my boyfriend at the time. After she’d asked me about 20 questions, she let her curiosity get the best of her and asked me one last question. She asked what kind of “stuff” I did with him. Specifically, she wanted to know if we made out. Being the honest kid that I was, I looked her dead in the eye and said “Yeah. All the time.” She turned beet red and said “Ugh! I can’t believe you just told me that!” I will never forget that moment.
Fast forward a few years and I’ve become the Truth Crusader, cape and all. Been tellin’ a lie? I’m on it! Through my Truth Crusades, though, I’ve realized that, like my aunt, I don’t think I always want to know the truth—at least not the truth I don’t already suspect. Plus, the truth isn’t always necessary. I learned this recently when I told a friend something I’m not sure she wanted to hear about someone important in her life. In that case, the truth was hurtful. More importantly, though, the truth became a big fat lie, as the he-said she-said drama behind the issue unfolded.
While I don’t always want to know the truth, I always want honesty. For me, there’s a big difference. The truth lies buried deep within our secrets, or at least the things people don’t know about us. To be honest, I think we’re all allowed to have our truths—the things others aren’t privy too and would never suspect (as long as we aren’t serial killers or other social deviants). The truth about some people is that they work for PETA but support Michael Vick each and every Sunday. Would it be scandalous to discover this information? Absolutely. Would this PETA employee be fired from his position as head dog advocate?Most definitely. Does this person’s truth really prevent him from being the best PETA employee this side of the Mississipi? Not at all.
Honesty, however, is the stuff we’re obliged to tell people because it affects them. There’s the I’m-going-to-tell-you-everything-no-matter-WHAT kind of honesty. But, there’s also the I-asked-you-a-question-and-you-gave-me-an-honest-answer kind. The former is nice, but the latter is required. I don’t really need to know every seedy and dark detail of a person’s life (as long as they aren’t serial killers or other social deviants). I just want answers to the things I want to know. Keyword: WANT to know. As long as I have that, I’m fine. Really. You can spare me the gory details of that time you ran over a cat…on purpose. I appreciate the brutal tell-all honesty, but I do perfectly fine not knowing that you’re a deranged animal abuser/hater.
Of course, the dilemma here is deciphering what it is you WANT to know. I suppose the litmus test will simply be answering whether or not you can live without knowing the truth and if the truth would, in fact, be a deal breaker. Otherwise, the truth is probably more upsetting than it is helpful. So, while I’ll still be a strong advocate for the truth and total honesty, I think I’ll hang up my Truth Crusader cape for a while. It’s time to let my friends and myself live in ignorance and, of course, bliss.


